Skip to content
BetaVoices
BetaVoices
Egypt press freedom

US senator links Egypt press crackdown to aid waiver

Chris Murphy says the Trump administration's decision to lift human rights conditions on military funding preceded arrests of journalists. The State Department cites national security interests

90 Trust score
90/100 Well backed by other sources

An independent AI check searched the web for this story's main claims. The newsroom cannot change this score.

  • Confirmed elsewhere 4 of 5
  • Not found either way 1 of 5
  • Disputed elsewhere 0 of 5

Our verification desk checked this story, and an editor approved it before it was published.

See how we checked this
Source language: English
0
US senator links Egypt press crackdown to aid waiver
Location
Washington
Washington, United States
Sen. Chris Murphy says lifting human rights conditions on $320 million in military aid led to Egypt's crackdown on independent media. The State Department points to security cooperation.

Democratic Sen. Chris Murphy blamed a crackdown on independent journalism in Egypt on the Trump administration's decision to waive human rights conditions on US military funding to the country, saying this week the two were clearly linked.

Murphy, who sits on the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, spoke at the Middle East Institute in Washington. "The minute that money was released, the crackdown began in an absolutely devastating way," he said. He accused the US government of abandoning the Egyptian people after it lifted restrictions tied to more than $300 million in defence assistance.

The BBC reported that over the past month, journalists at two of Egypt's few remaining independent news outlets have been arrested. On Tuesday, a court in Cairo ordered the closure of the news website Madr Masr and fined its editor-in-chief, Lina Attalah. Amnesty International called the verdict "a crushing blow to press freedom."

Earlier this month, authorities arrested six journalists at the fact-checking platform Matsda2sh and charged them with belonging to the outlawed Muslim Brotherhood.

The US State Department told the BBC it waived conditions on a portion of military aid in September because of Egypt's "importance to US national security interests." It cited the "concrete security cooperation Egypt provides to the United States" and said it maintains dialogue with Cairo on a "full range of issues" but would "not comment on private diplomatic conversations."

Secretary of State Marco Rubio waived human rights conditions on $320 million of the aid, according to a letter sent to congressional committees. A Sept. 4 memo bearing his signature, seen by Reuters, called the waiver "essential" given Egypt's "helpful role following Operation Epic Fury." Egypt assisted negotiations between the US and Iran.

US law allows up to $320 million of the roughly $1.3 billion in annual aid to be withheld unless Egypt meets democracy and human rights requirements, but the administration can waive the conditions on national security grounds. A similar waiver was issued in 2024 under President Joe Biden.

Murphy, who chairs a congressional committee on the Middle East and counterterrorism, said he has criticized both administrations. "To the extent that there was any glimmer left of political speech in Egypt, it is gone for one proximate reason: The United States government abandoned the people of Egypt and decided to remove all conditions on our funding," he said.

Timothy E. Kaldas, deputy director of the Tahrir Institute for Middle East Policy, said the Attalah conviction and the Madr Masr closure marked an unprecedented escalation in repression of press freedom in Egypt. He said the US and European Union have prioritized strategic ties over human rights.

The Egyptian Embassy in Washington did not respond to a request for comment from the BBC. President Abdel Fattah al-Sisi has denied there are political prisoners in Egypt.

How this story was checked

Trust score: 90 out of 100. An independent AI check searched the web for the story's main claims. The score comes only from what it found, so the newsroom cannot change it. How the score works

  1. Rubio waived human rights conditions on $320 million of US military aid to Egypt, citing Egypt's "helpful role" after the Iran war began. (confirmed elsewhere)
    AP and Reuters both reported the $320 million waiver. They said it cited Egypt's help in dealing with Iran. The story's "Operation Epic Fury" wording and the Sept. 4 memo date were not checked.
    Rubio waives human rights restrictions to release $320 million in military aid to Egypt (AP)
    Reuters exclusive on X
  2. A Cairo court ordered the closure of Mada Masr ("Madr Masr" in the story) and fined editor-in-chief Lina Attalah. Amnesty called it "a crushing blow to press freedom." (confirmed elsewhere)
    Mada Masr reported that a New Cairo court fined Attalah LE3 million and ordered the site closed, on a charge of running an unlicensed website. The BBC report carried by Ada Derana includes the Amnesty quote. The story misspells the outlet's name.
    Lina Attalah in custody after court issues LE3 mn fine, orders Mada Masr's closure
    Egypt court fines journalist Lina Attalah and orders news site's closure
  3. Authorities arrested six journalists at fact-checking platform Matsda2sh and charged them with belonging to the outlawed Muslim Brotherhood. (confirmed elsewhere)
    The Media Line, IPI and ABC News report the arrest of Matsda2sh's six-person newsroom over alleged Muslim Brotherhood links. IPI says Egypt's Interior Ministry confirmed the detentions and made the accusation.
    Egypt: Authorities arrest entire Matsadaash newsroom, charge them with terrorism (IPI)
    Egypt Arrests Entire Newsroom Over Alleged Muslim Brotherhood Ties (The Media Line)
  4. Murphy said at the Middle East Institute that the crackdown began "the minute that money was released," and the State Department cited security cooperation. (confirmed elsewhere)
    Yahoo's report on the BBC story places Murphy at the Middle East Institute and carries the State Department's national-security justification. Some of this is quoted opinion, so it confirms that he said it, not that it is true.
    Democratic senator blames Egypt press crackdown on Trump military aid decision
  5. The aid waiver led to Egypt's crackdown on independent media. (not found either way)
    This is Murphy's view. I found no independent evidence on what caused the arrests and the closure. Egypt's government gives other reasons, such as an unlicensed website and Muslim Brotherhood links.

An editor checked 4 claims in this story against 1 source before it was published.

  • Claims checked: 4. Sources used: 1.
  • 4 could not be independently confirmed.

Sources the newsroom lists

  1. Democratic senator blames Egypt press crackdown on US military aid decision (News report or publication)

Independent web check on Oct. 30, 2026. Checked by our verification desk on Oct. 30, 2026. An editor approved the story before it was published. Our standards

Comments

Comments (0)

Please log in to comment.

No comments yet.

Up next

Kenya Kenya health minister halts US-backed Ebola centre after court rebuke Similar coverage Aden Duale apologized in court and said construction at the Nanyuki military base had been stopped after a judge found he ignored an earlier order

Support BetaVoices

Our reporting is free to read. Readers who support BetaVoices keep it that way.